Follow OHIOcitizenact on Twitter

Heartland Petroleum defends itself

William Snedegar, President, Heartland Petroleum

COLUMBUS – Heartland Petroleum has sent Ohio Citizen Action a two-page memo defending its Columbus operations. In referring to the power outage that triggered a December 2009 accident, the company said, “Heartland has repeatedly requested support from AEP because power interruptions of more than 1 second are harmful to our system. Heartland has installed equipment that will sustain up to 8 seconds of power interruption, but additional support from AEP is still needed.”

Ohio Citizen Action’s Kate Russell said, “Power outages happen. Imagine if other factories and houses throughout Columbus had accidents every time there was a 1-second or 8-second power outage. Nothing would function. The public would not accept it.”

Paul Ryder, Organizing Director, Ohio Citizen Action

Heartland Refinery has history of mishaps

NBC4 Columbus

Judge gives offending refinery one more chance

Hale reluctant to put out workers at East Side oil recycler

Judge Harland Hale

COLUMBUS — “Less than two weeks after threatening to close an East Side oil refinery if its odors continued to sicken neighbors, a Franklin County judge gave the plant another chance yesterday.

‘I want to try one last-ditch effort before I shut it down,’ Environmental Judge Harland H. Hale said after a hearing on the most-recent smelly emissions from the Heartland Petroleum Refinery.

Instead, Hale ordered attorneys for the state and Heartland to choose an objective expert to conduct a “comprehensive maintenance review” of the plant and develop a plan to correct the problem. The state wanted the judge to close the plant, which recycles used motor oil, until the plan is developed.”

— John Futty, Columbus Dispatch

Read the whole story

Heartland Refinery’s final chance to clean up its act

ABC6 Columbus

Ohio EPA again investigating East Side refinery

COLUMBUS — “Investigators from the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency on Monday were looking into complaints against an east side refinery that is in danger of being closed.

The Ohio EPA said it received several complaints, beginning on Monday afternoon, from people near the Heartland Petroleum plant on East 5th Avenue, 10TV’s Danielle Elias reported.

An EPA spokeswoman said the agency received complaints of a “burnt oil smell.”

The complaints come 11 days after the company faced an environmental court judge, who warned that Heartland could be shut down.

Franklin County Environmental Court Judge Harland Hale on Aug. 19 ruled that Heartland Petroleum could remain open, but warned the company that if it had another release of chemical fumes it could be closed.”

WBNS

Read the whole story

Judge warns refinery, denies closure request

COLUMBUS — “A judge on Thursday afternoon denied a request by the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency to close an east side refinery.

Franklin County Environmental Court Judge Harland Hale ruled that Heartland Petroleum can remain open for now, but warned the company that if it has another release of chemical fumes it could be closed, 10TV’s Glenn McEntyre reported.

The Ohio Attorney Generals office had filed a complaint against Heartland, which was being heard in court this week.”

WBNS 10TV

Read the whole story

Watch the video

Refinery on notice over stench

Judge issues ultimatum after odors made workers sick

COLUMBUS — “A Franklin County judge warned the operator of an East Side oil refinery yesterday that he will shut down the plant if there are any more releases of chemical odors that have sickened workers in neighboring buildings.

The order came after a two-hour emergency hearing during which the Ohio attorney general’s office asked Environmental Court Judge Harland H. Hale to close the Heartland Petroleum Refinery until the odor problem can be corrected.

Hale said he hopes his ultimatum motivates the company to speed up efforts to address the issue, which has generated complaints since the plant began operating early last year.

‘I have to do something to ensure the safety of the neighborhood,’ he said.”

— John Futty, Columbus Dispatch

Read the whole story

Ohio Citizen Action wants restraining order against Heartland Petroleum operations

Ohio EPA Director Chris Korleski and Attorney General Richard Cordray

COLUMBUS — Ohio Citizen Action today pressed Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray and Ohio EPA Director Chris Korleski to seek an immediate temporary restraining order to stop operations at Heartland Petroleum in Columbus.

Heartland Petroleum cleans used oil to be sold and reused. Since it opened in March 2009, Heartland “engaged in the uncontrolled release of sulfur-containing compounds and/or other odorous compounds. This has resulted in numerous complaints from neighboring businesses and from the Columbus Fire Department,” according to the (State of Ohio) lawsuit.

669 Ohio Citizen Action members have sent letters to Heartland Refinery Group CEO and President Bill Snedegar, urging him to use the most up to date pollution and odor controls on the facility and work with neighbors and businesses so they can coexist safely.

Kate Russell, Organizer, Ohio Citizen Action

Read the press release

Read the letter to Chris Korleski and Richard Cordray

Heartland Petroleum—what’s the problem?

Heartland Petroleum is owned by Columbus based Heartland Refinery Group. This facility is located on the east side of Columbus and recycles used motor oil to be sold and reused. The Columbus Fire Department, area businesses, and passers-by began complaining to the Ohio EPA about the odors coming from Heartland Petroleum as soon as the facility opened in March 2009. Employees in neighboring businesses have been able to smell the sulfurous odor both outside and inside of their workplaces.

Airborne toxins

Heartland Petroleum has been cited by the Ohio EPA for continuously emitting sulfur dioxide and hydrogen chloride into the air, violating their permits. On December 14, Heartland Petroleum had a power failure which resulted in the release of hydrogen gas and hydrogen sulfide.

According to the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry—

Sulfur Dioxide

Long-term exposure to persistent levels of sulfur dioxide can affect your health. Lung function changes were seen in some workers exposed to low levels of sulfur dioxide for 20 years or more. However, these workers were also exposed to other chemicals, so their health effects may not have been from sulfur dioxide alone. Asthmatics have also been shown to be sensitive to the respiratory effects of low concentrations of sulfur dioxide. Children who live in or near heavily industrialized areas where sulfur dioxide occurs may experience difficulty breathing, changes in the ability to breathe deeply, and burning of the nose and throat.

Hydrogen Chloride

Hydrogen chloride is irritating and corrosive to any tissue it contacts. Brief exposure to low levels causes throat irritation. Exposure to higher levels can result in rapid breathing, narrowing of the bronchioles, blue coloring of the skin, accumulation of fluid in the lungs, and even death. Exposure to even higher levels can cause swelling and spasm of the throat and suffocation. Some people may develop an inflammatory reaction to hydrogen chloride.

Hydrogen Sulfide

Exposure to low concentrations of hydrogen sulfide may cause irritation to the eyes, nose, or throat. It may also cause difficulty in breathing for some asthmatics. Brief exposures to high concentrations of hydrogen sulfide (greater than 500 parts per million) can cause a loss of consciousness and possibly death. In most cases, the person appears to regain consciousness without any other effects. However, in many individuals, there may be permanent or long-term effects such as headaches, poor attention span, poor memory, and poor motor function. Because hydrogen sulfide is heavier than air and because children are shorter than adults, children sometimes are exposed to more hydrogen sulfide than adults. Health problems in children who have been exposed to hydrogen sulfide have not been studied much. Exposed children probably will experience effects similar to those experienced by exposed adults.

Worker hazards

Heartland Petroleum has been cited by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration for a number of serious worker safety violations.  Some of these violations have been fixed, but not all.  Citations include —

• failure to label piping with flammable or combustible liquid

• not supplying protective equipment for employees handling hazardous materials

• not supplying eye wash stations for emergency use

• failure to supply blocks on energy supplies to equipment during maintenance

• failure to conduct routine inspection for controls on hazardous energy

• failure to provide adequate training to employees for emergency procedures and safe working practices to avoid electrical shock, chemical burns, and other injuries

• inadequate alarm system to alert employees of hazardous situations

Community hazards

Near-by businesses and residents are exposed to toxins by Heartland Petroleum because the company has been violating State of Ohio by—

• bypassing required pollution controls, including uncontrolled releases of sulfur dioxide and hydrogen chloride

• repeated complaints of nuisance odors from neighboring businesses

• failing to conduct required emissions testing

• loading railcars without a permit, creating another source of air pollution

According to the Ohio EPA, these violations are “an imminent threat to human health and the environment.”

Accident prone

On December 14, 2009, Heartland Petroleum had a leak, which included hydrogen sulfide, causing the evacuation of 4,000 employees from area businesses. Officials from Heartland blamed a temporary power outage for the leak. American Electric Power said the facility was without power for no more than ten seconds.

On July 17, 2010, warm oil was spilled and came into contact with a hydrogen tank. A gasket blew, causing a pipe to catch fire.

What is the EPA doing?

On June 15, 2010, the State of Ohio filed a lawsuit against Heartland Refinery Group for their environmental violations. The trial assignment is set for June 14, 2011. This gives an entire year for Heartland Petroleum to continue to bypass pollution controls, ignore their permits, contaminate the local businesses and residents with toxins, and have more accidents. It is highly possible that this date will be pushed back even further, and there’s no guarantee how the court will rule, how strict it will be, how long the court will give Heartland to comply, nor how long it will actually take Heartland to comply.

For more information

Kate Russell

614-263-4600

Oil spill prompts refinery fire

Heartland Petroleum

COLUMBUS — “Fire crews battled a blaze at an oil refinery on Saturday night after a passing motorist noticed smoke coming from one of the tanks. Crews were called to Heartland Petroleum, located at 4001 East 5th Avenue, on the city’s east side, around 10:30 p.m., 10TV News reported. An oil tank at the business was on fire. Employees were evacuated and no injuries were reported.

Firefighters said crews were transporting warm oil when some of it spilled near a hydrogen tank, blowing out a gasket, and causing a pipe to catch fire. ‘I think it’s just a natural hazard that can occur when you’re moving hot oil around and you’re moving this around,’ said Battalion Chief Michael Fowler. ‘There’s safeties and everything to shut everything down. There are release valves for everything, but accidents are going to occur.’”

10TV News

Read the whole story

Columbus oil refinery sued by Ohio EPA

State says company violating air pollution limits

COLUMBUS — “Less than a year after Heartland Refinery Group was praised by city and state officials as a cutting edge “green” business, the company has been sued by the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency for violating air pollution limits.

In the process, the state says Heartland created “a substantial odor nuisance and potential adverse impacts to public health and the environment.”

The state’s action is a substantial blow to the plant, dubbed a “re-refinery” because it strips soot and other compounds from used motor oil so that it could be recycled. Heartland officials planned to recycle as much as 20 million gallons of used oil a year.

The plant ran into trouble two months after its official ribbon cutting when a power failure triggered a hydrogen sulfide gas leak at the facility. More than 4,000 people were evacuated from nearby businesses.”

— Spencer Hunt, Columbus Dispatch

Read the whole story